Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Litz's avatar

Tom, thanks for a thought-provoking post. Your historical examples make a strong case for AI’s place in music. Betting against it probably would likely make me the guy in 1906 shorting the phonograph.

But what happens when polished songs and manufactured artists become limitless yet our attention doesn’t?

Verified human authorship could become more valuable. Helping a musician create is different from generating the song, singer, and backstory. I can enjoy a breakup song and still wonder whether anyone actually got dumped.

Vinyl’s renewed appeal offers a useful parallel. Convenience didn’t erase our appetite for a tangible connection to music. AI’s abundance could deepen our desire for a human one.

That means credible verification: who wrote it, who performed it, and where AI contributed. “Human-made” should be something listeners can trust, not just a sticker on the album cover.

The transition could be rough. Musicians may face greater competition for streams and pressure on publishing income. But those who sustain their craft and audience connection may eventually command a premium.

I’ve been digging deep on a business idea around this with a longtime music-industry friend. Once we have it dialed, I’d love to run our rough mix past your ears.

When AI can make endless music, will knowing a human made it become the thing worth paying for?

Silvia Johncy's avatar

Tom! Loved the piece! Brevity is the soul of wit, and perhaps something uniquely human, or so I believe. AI is a wonderful tool that can help us get there faster, but the end result, much like a game of chess, is unique to each individual, even though we all begin with the same 64 squares and 32 pieces.

Here's a playful thought experiment: What if we applied the Ship of Theseus paradox to music? If an artist gradually replaced every element of a song with AI-generated components, one piece at a time, at what point would it stop being the artist's music and become AI's? Or does the artist's intent make it theirs regardless of how much AI contributed?

4 more comments...

Ready for more?